Endy vs Douglas vs Casper in Canada: What Owners Say After Sleeping on It for a Year

Endy has the strongest track record here: 10 of its 12 mentions are positive, and several owners report 5 to 8 years of use with no sagging or complaints — "we still love it" and "no sagging or dips or anything, pretty much feels like day 1" are typical at the 5-year mark. Douglas tells a more divided story. Multiple owners report 5+ years of solid performance, including one who's owned two Douglas mattresses and calls it "holding up well 5+ years on," but Douglas also has the pack's clearest failure reports: one owner's mattress was "good for 3.5 years" before it had to be thrown out due to mold, and another describes visible depressions becoming noticeable "after year 3 or so" on a mattress they wouldn't buy again. Casper's single long-term report is strongly positive — an owner six years in calls it "the best sleep ever" — but with only 4 total mentions, that's a much thinner base to generalize from than Endy's or Douglas's.

This is where Douglas owners are most vocal, and mostly favorable: one owner chose it specifically for medical back and joint conditions and cites its 20-year no-sag warranty as the deciding factor, and another who owned both says "prefer the Douglas by far — I used to wake up with lower back pain with the Endy. Haven't had that problem with the Douglas." That's not universal, though — a different Douglas owner (6'4", 230 lbs) reports "intense lower back pain after only 1 year." Endy's back-support mentions run positive, including from two separate owners managing chronic back injuries who describe it as consistently comfortable and supportive years in. Casper's one back-support mention is negative: an owner who found the hybrid "super soft (like a cloud!)" reports waking up with back problems, in contrast to a firmer version of the mattress they compare it to.

Endy's own listed tradeoff is a firmer first week that softens after roughly 30 nights, and the mentions mostly bear that out as a non-issue once settled — most owners describe the medium feel as comfortable and correctly firm for their build. The exception is a couple who "hated ours — it was unbelievably soft" as self-described "rock hard mattress people," a reminder that Endy's medium feel doesn't suit everyone. Douglas is built medium-firm, a step firmer than the Endy per its own product data, which the pack's back-pain-relief mentions are consistent with. Casper's single break-in mention describes a rough start that improved after the owner rotated the mattress 180 degrees, calling it a mix of "breaking it in" and the rotation itself — a smaller, more anecdotal data point than the firmness patterns on the other two.

Edge support is Endy's one acknowledged soft spot — an 8/10 subscore versus 8.7 for Casper — and it shows up in the mentions: one owner's only complaint about two Endy mattresses is that "the edges are soft," requiring a taller bed frame to avoid pinching when sitting on the side. On value, Douglas is the standout: a 9.5/10 value subscore, the lowest price of the three at ~$699 CAD, and no mention in the pack raises price as a concern. Casper is the opposite case — at ~$1299 CAD it's the most expensive of the three, and two of its four mentions raise cost directly, including an owner who bought in-store and was "thinking of returning it" to buy the cheaper Costco-sold version instead.