ClearPick compared three automatic pet feeders sold in Canada, but the underlying data is lopsided: only the PETLIBRO Granary WiFi has verified owner mentions in this pack — 8 of them, split roughly evenly between positive, negative, and mixed. The PetSafe Smart Feed 2 and WOpet Camera Feeder currently have zero logged owner mentions, so their sections below rely on ClearPick's product assessment (subscores, pros, cons, and verdict) rather than sourced quotes. The PETLIBRO leads on score at 8.3/10, with the PetSafe and WOpet trailing behind it.
1. PETLIBRO Granary WiFi — the camera feeder with real owner data behind it
The PETLIBRO Granary WiFi scores 8.3/10 on the strength of 8 owner mentions — 3 positive, 3 negative, and 2 mixed, the only product in this comparison with any verified sentiment data. The split tells a consistent story: the camera and remote scheduling genuinely work when the WiFi connection holds, and WiFi is exactly where it breaks down. On the positive side, one owner reports the feeder 'automatically reconnected to the wifi as soon as it was working again, without any issues' after an hour-long outage, and another had it running smoothly for six months. On the negative side, one owner with six units reports three of them disconnecting one after another — 'so annoying for this much money' — and another gave up entirely after 'hours and hours of failed attempts connecting to my wifi,' calling it 'a door stop' until PETLIBRO fixes the issue. The mixed-sentiment mentions land in between: workarounds exist, like switching a router to WPA3 or toggling a 2.4GHz-band device, but they require troubleshooting most buyers won't expect to do. Best for owners who want camera verification and are willing to spend some setup time getting the WiFi connection stable.
2. PetSafe Smart Feed 2 — no owner mentions yet, but the strongest specs on paper
The PetSafe Smart Feed 2 scores 7.3/10, the middle of this comparison, but that score currently rests entirely on ClearPick's product assessment — the pack has zero logged owner mentions for this unit, so nothing here is a direct quote. Portion Accuracy is its standout subscore at 90/100, tied to an auger-driven dispensing mechanism the product write-up describes as consistent to within 1-2 pieces of kibble per feeding, versus the 20-30% variance typical of gravity-based dispensers. The 24-cup hopper and slow-feed mode, which spreads a meal over 15 minutes, are also called out as genuine advantages for dogs on strict diets or fast eaters. Value is its weakest subscore at 75/100 — at $189 CAD it's the most expensive product in this comparison, and it's the only one of the three without a camera. Best for owners prioritizing precise, verified portion control over camera monitoring, with the caveat that no owner reports currently back up that assessment.
3. WOpet Camera Feeder — the budget option, also without owner mentions yet
The WOpet Camera Feeder scores 7.0/10, the lowest of the three, and like the PetSafe it has zero logged owner mentions in this pack — its section rests on ClearPick's product assessment rather than sourced quotes. At $79 CAD it's the cheapest product here by a wide margin, and Value is its highest subscore at 90/100 for bundling app scheduling, a built-in camera, voice-message recording, and a 6L hopper at a fraction of the PETLIBRO or PetSafe price. The tradeoffs are consistent with that price gap: the camera is 720p rather than PETLIBRO's 1080p and is described as producing a 'grainy image' in low light, portion accuracy can vary by ±10-15% due to a gravity-assisted mechanism, and there's no battery backup for power outages. Best for owners testing automatic feeding for the first time who don't need precise portion control or camera clarity.
Best For
| PETLIBRO Granary WiFi… | PetSafe Smart Feed 2 | WOPET Automatic Cat F… | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value | Value 90/100 | — | ✓ Value 90/100, cheapest |
| Price | $170 | — | ✓ Cheapest, $79 |
| Camera / remote monitoring | ✓ 1080P + night vision | — | 720P, grainy in low light |
| Verified owner mentions | ✓ 8 mentions | — | — |
Who It’s For
The only feeder here with real owner data — the camera and scheduling get consistent praise, but recurring WiFi dropout complaints mean you should budget setup time.
See review →
The strongest on-paper case for accurate dispensing and large capacity, but no owner mentions exist yet to confirm ClearPick's assessment in practice.
See review →
The cheapest of the three by a wide margin, with a lower-resolution camera and looser portion accuracy — and no owner mentions yet to verify real-world performance.
See review →What owners actually say
What buyers love
“So far it's been great! The feeder has been super reliable so far. A few times my wifi was down for an hour or so and the feeder automatically reconnected to the wifi as soon as it was working again, without any issues.”
r/Petlibro
“I had no issues setting up the device using my phone (took 5 minutes on Android). I used the bluetooth option for setup. The feeder worked immediately on my 5GHz wifi without issues.”
r/Petlibro
“No drawbacks that I've noticed but I never tried the cloud plan. Everytime i go into the video library it tries to get me to get the cloud plan too, but other then that this thing has been awesome”
r/Petlibro
Common complaints
Multiple units losing WiFi connection
I bought 6 and have three set up. One was disconnected. Now the other two have followed. So annoying for this much money.
r/CatAdviceSetup failures leave the feeder unusable
Maybe it only works with android because I cannot get mine to connect for the life of me. Hours and hours of failed attempts connecting to my wifi. It is now a door stop unfortunately until PETLIBRO can rectify the issue
r/PetlibroOf the three, only the PETLIBRO Granary WiFi has real owner sentiment behind it, and that data is genuinely split — the camera and scheduling work well when the connection holds, and WiFi dropouts are a recurring, sometimes serious frustration. At $170 CAD it's the strongest overall pick in this comparison, particularly for owners who want the camera. The PetSafe Smart Feed 2 has the best on-paper case for precise portion control and is the largest-capacity option, worth considering for dogs on strict diets — but treat its 7.3/10 as an assessment, not a verified track record, until owner mentions accumulate. The WOpet Camera Feeder is a reasonable low-cost entry point at $79 CAD for owners who just want to try automatic feeding, with the same caveat: no owner mentions yet to confirm the assessment.